SVSYSTEMS

Index / Language / Records / Italian / Grammar

Participle agreement

Whether the past participle changes its ending, and with what. Narrow, exceptionless, and directly examinable.

Italian · Grammar · GRM-08

The control text · argumentative

Vietare il cellulare in classe sembra una misura drastica, ma i dati suggeriscono che funzioni. Nelle scuole che hanno introdotto il divieto, gli insegnanti segnalano meno interruzioni e un calo dei casi di cyberbullismo. È vero che lo strumento serve anche allo studio, e sarebbe ingenuo negarlo. Resta il fatto che il costo della distrazione ricade su chi ha meno sostegno a casa. Finché non ci saranno prove che l'uso libero migliori l'apprendimento, l'onere della prova spetta a chi difende il permesso.

Every option below rewrites this text.

Where the two part

Standard · the base

With essere it agrees with the subject. With avere it agrees only with a preceding direct-object clitic, and is otherwise invariable.

Regional · the contrast

The clitic agreement is variably applied in speech. In writing it is expected, and its absence is one of the quieter markers of a non-native text.

10 options

GRM-08a

With essere — agrees with the subject

Standard

L'abbonamento è stato chiuso. · Le ricevute sono arrivate.

The tellessere plus a participle that changes its ending to match the subject.

Gains

Anchor A contains one. Identical in principle to Spanish and Portuguese passives, so it transfers.

Costs

It requires the auxiliary choice on GRM-02 to be right first.

GRM-08b

With avere — invariable

Standard

Ho disdetto il servizio. · Ho conservato le ricevute.

The tellNo agreement at all, whatever the object's gender or number.

Gains

Anchor A contains this too. The default, and it means most participles simply do not change.

Costs

Its very regularity makes the clitic exception below easy to forget.

GRM-08c

With avere and a preceding clitic

Standard

Ho visto la ricevuta → L'ho vista. · Ho visto le ricevute → Le ho viste.

The tellA direct-object clitic in front pulls agreement onto the participle. Nothing else with avere does.

Gains

The single highest-value rule on this sheet: narrow, absolute, and an examiner will notice it either way.

Costs

Only direct object clitics trigger it, so le ho parlato stays invariable and looks identical on the page.

GRM-08d

With ne

Standard

Ne ho conservate due. — the participle agrees with what ne stands for

The tellAgreement with a quantity that is not written in the sentence.

Gains

Follows the same logic as the clitic rule, so learning one covers both.

Costs

The thing being agreed with is invisible, which makes the rule feel arbitrary until it clicks.

GRM-08e

With a reflexive

Standard

Mi sono accorto dell'addebito. · Maria si è accorta.

The tellReflexive means essere, which means agreement with the subject.

Gains

Absolute, and it follows from GRM-02 rather than being a separate fact.

Costs

With a reflexive that has its own direct object the picture changes, and that is where it gets genuinely difficult.

GRM-08f

With the impersonal si

Standard

Si è andati in banca. · Si è stati fortunati.

The tellMasculine plural after a singular si.

Gains

A rule with no exceptions, frequent in formal writing, and it looks wrong until you know it is right.

Costs

It is counter-intuitive enough that learners correct it back to the singular.

GRM-08g

Si passivante — agrees

Standard

Standard Si vendono case. — passive, agrees

Regional Si dice che… — impersonal, singular

The tellWhether the verb agrees with the thing being sold tells you which si you are looking at.

Gains

The clearest way to separate the two si constructions, which otherwise look identical.

Costs

Both appear constantly and the distinction is invisible until you test the agreement.

GRM-08h

With a modal

Standard

Standard Sono dovuto andare.

Regional Ho dovuto andare.

The tellWhether the modal borrowed essere from its infinitive, and whether the participle then agrees.

Gains

Honest complexity: both forms are in print, so this is a genuinely open question rather than a rule.

Costs

Because both are defensible, it is a poor place to be assertive in either direction.

GRM-08i

Agreement omitted after a clitic

Standard

L'ho visto for a feminine object — grammatical-looking and wrong

The tellAn invariable participle where a preceding clitic required agreement.

Gains

On the sheet because it is the most common quiet error in advanced writing: nothing sounds wrong.

Costs

It is marked in both exam lanes, and it is the kind of error that survives years of fluency.

GRM-08j

Agreement over-applied

Standard

Ho conservate le ricevute — wrong: no preceding clitic, so no agreement

The tellAgreement with a following object.

Gains

Named because it is what happens immediately after the clitic rule is learned.

Costs

Wrong in every register, and it signals a rule half-applied rather than a slip.